The barn smelled like fresh hay and warm animals when Rebecca slipped inside after dark. At nineteen she was on her Rumspringa, and the English boy she had met at the county fair had already taught her how good it felt to spread her legs. Tonight she had brought her friend Sarah along. Sarah was eighteen, still in her plain dress and bonnet, but her eyes were wide with the same hunger Rebecca felt every night now.
"Lock the door," Rebecca whispered. She pulled her dress over her head, leaving only her shift. Her nipples were already tight against the thin cloth. Sarah watched, breathing fast, then did the same. Both girls stood naked in the lantern light, pale skin and soft curves, the dark triangles of hair between their thighs already damp.
Rebecca pushed Sarah back onto a pile of blankets. "Spread your legs for me," she said, voice low and rough. Sarah obeyed, knees falling open. Rebecca dropped between them and licked straight up the center of Sarah's pussy, tasting salt and sweetness. Sarah gasped and grabbed Rebecca's hair. Rebecca licked harder, tongue flicking the little clit until Sarah's hips started jerking.
"Fuck, that feels dirty," Sarah moaned. "Don't stop."
Rebecca sucked the clit into her mouth and slid two fingers into Sarah's tight hole. She pumped them slowly at first, then faster, curling them to hit the spot that made Sarah cry out. Wet sounds filled the barn. Sarah came hard, thighs clamping around Rebecca's head, pussy pulsing and dripping down Rebecca's chin.
They switched places. Sarah got on all fours and Rebecca knelt behind her, rubbing her own soaked cunt against Sarah's ass. She reached around and fingered Sarah again while grinding. "You like being a bad Amish girl?" Rebecca growled. "You like getting your cunt licked in a barn?"
"Yes," Sarah panted.
"I want more. Put your fingers in my ass too."
Rebecca spit on Sarah's tight hole and worked a finger in while still fucking her pussy with the other hand. Sarah pushed back, taking it deeper, moaning like a whore. Rebecca's own juices ran down her thighs. She kept going until Sarah came again, shaking and swearing in Pennsylvania Dutch.
Then Sarah turned and shoved Rebecca onto her back. She spread Rebecca's legs wide and buried her face in her cunt, licking and sucking like she was starving. Rebecca held her own knees open and watched Sarah's tongue work. "Suck my clit harder," she ordered. Sarah obeyed, lips sealed around it, two fingers thrusting deep. Rebecca came with a long, filthy moan, flooding Sarah's mouth.
They kept going until both girls were sweaty and spent, lying tangled on the blankets. Outside the crickets sang and the world stayed quiet, but inside the barn two Amish girls had just fucked each other raw and weren't finished yet.
